Papa John’s Garlic Sauce

Don’t want to hear the backstory? Jump straight to the recipe. Papa John’s has been serving their garlic sauce with pizzas since they opened. The warm, buttery sauce goes perfectly with pizzas and breadsticks. There are countless recipes online for recreating it (mostly involving mixing garlic powder into melted butter) which make a pretty good result, but there is something off about them. At the test kitchen, we wanted to truly rebuild the sauce in a home kitchen, so we started from the ground up. If you look at the… Read More »Papa John’s Garlic Sauce